Social Identity Theory: What Tajfel & Turner Said in 1979
Social identity theory, developed by Henri Tajfel and John Turner in 1979, proposes that part of who you are comes from the groups you belong to, and that people favor their own groups to protect a positive sense of self.
That sounds obvious until you see the evidence behind it. In the early 1970s, teenage boys sorted into groups by a meaningless art preference chose to give their own group less, as long as it meant beating the other group. That choice is the puzzle the whole theory was built to explain.
Key Takeaways
- Tajfel and Turner’s 1979 chapter and the 1986 version are not the same citation, and knowing which one to use can save you points on your next paper.
- Schoolboys split into groups by a trivial art preference made a reward choice that surprised even the researchers, and it still shapes how psychologists explain prejudice.
- The theory says people want their group to be better, not just good, and that single idea explains a surprising range of everyday behavior.
- When a group is stuck at low status, members respond in one of three predictable ways, depending on how fixed the hierarchy feels.
- The popular self-esteem explanation for group bias has weaker support than most textbooks suggest.
Who Developed Social Identity Theory?
Henri Tajfel was a Polish-born Jewish psychologist whose life story shaped his research. While serving in the French army, he was captured by German forces in 1940. He survived the war in prisoner-of-war camps by presenting himself as French and concealing his Polish Jewish background. Most of his family died in the Holocaust.
After studying psychology at Birkbeck College in London, Tajfel taught at Durham and Oxford. In 1967 he became chair of social psychology at the University of Bristol, where he ran his minimal group experiments and later worked with John Turner.
Their joint 1979 chapter laid out the full theory. Turner later developed self-categorization theory with colleagues, and the two theories are now often grouped together as the social identity approach (Hornsey, 2008).
Earlier research had already linked group competition to hostility. The Robbers Cave Experiment in 1954 showed how quickly rivalry between groups of boys turned hostile. Tajfel’s key contribution was showing that competition is not even required.
1979 vs 1986: Which Tajfel and Turner Paper Should You Cite?
Many students search for the 1979 citation and then find a 1986 one in their textbook. Both are real. The 1979 chapter, titled “An integrative theory of intergroup conflict,” appeared in a book edited by Austin and Worchel (Tajfel & Turner, 1979).
A revised version, retitled “The social identity theory of intergroup behavior,” appeared in 1986 in a volume edited by Worchel and Austin (Tajfel & Turner, 1986). The core ideas are the same, but only the 1986 title uses the name of the theory.
The safe rule is to cite the version you actually read. If your instructor asks for the original statement of Tajfel and Turner’s social identity theory, use 1979. Many journal articles cite both at once, written as (Tajfel & Turner, 1979, 1986). Full APA references for both are in the reference list below.

The Interpersonal-Intergroup Continuum
One idea from the 1979 chapter that often gets skipped is the interpersonal-intergroup continuum. Tajfel and Turner described social behavior as falling somewhere between two extremes (Tajfel & Turner, 1979).
At the interpersonal end, people interact purely as individuals, and their group memberships barely matter. Two close friends chatting sit near this end. At the intergroup end, people act almost entirely as representatives of their groups. Tajfel’s classic example is soldiers fighting an opposing army.
Social identity theory is mainly about behavior near the intergroup end. The closer a situation moves toward that pole, the more uniformly group members behave and the more they treat out-group members as interchangeable.
The Three Core Processes
Social identity theory rests on three connected processes. Each one moves a person further from thinking as an individual and deeper into thinking as a group member.
Social Categorization
Social categorization is the habit of sorting people, yourself included, into groups: students and professors, locals and tourists, home fans and away fans. It happens quickly and mostly without effort.
The catch is that categorization exaggerates differences between groups and shrinks differences within them. People start to look like examples of a category rather than individuals.
Social Identification
Once you see yourself as part of a group, you begin to take on its identity. This is social identification. The group’s values and social norms become part of how you see yourself, so criticism of the group can feel like criticism of you.
Social Comparison
Finally, people compare their group with other groups. Leon Festinger’s social comparison theory had already shown that individuals size themselves up against other people. Tajfel and Turner applied the same logic to whole groups, with one twist: the goal is not an accurate comparison but a favorable one.
The Minimal Group Paradigm: Trivial Labels, Real Bias
In the minimal group studies, teenage schoolboys in Bristol were assigned to groups using trivial criteria, such as whether they overestimated or underestimated the number of dots on a screen, or preferred paintings by Klee or Kandinsky (Tajfel et al., 1971). They never met their fellow group members and had nothing personal to gain.
Each boy then divided rewards between two anonymous others, one from his own group and one from the other. Most boys favored their own group. More strikingly, many chose options that gave their own group less in absolute terms, as long as the gap between the two groups was larger.
That result stripped away the usual explanations for prejudice. There was no shared history, no competition and no self-interest at stake. Categorization alone was enough to trigger favoritism, and explaining why is the job social identity theory set out to do.
Positive Distinctiveness: Why Good Isn’t Enough
Why would anyone accept less just to beat a group of strangers? Tajfel and Turner’s answer is positive distinctiveness: the drive for your group to be not only good, but better than the groups it is compared with (Tajfel & Turner, 1979).
The logic runs in three steps. People want a positive self-concept. Part of that self-concept comes from group memberships. So people are motivated to see their groups as positively distinct from others. In the minimal group studies, widening the gap was the only way to make “my group” stand out.
Some textbooks list positive distinctiveness as a fourth process alongside categorization, identification and comparison. Either way, it is the motivational engine of the theory, and it explains why people tend to pick the comparisons where their own group looks best.
What Happens When Your Group Has Low Status?
Not every group can come out on top. When a group has low status, its members’ social identity becomes less satisfying, and Tajfel and Turner predicted three broad responses (Tajfel & Turner, 1979).
Which response people choose depends on two questions. Can individuals move freely into a higher-status group? And does the status gap feel stable and legitimate, or shaky and unfair?

Individual Mobility
If group boundaries are permeable, people can leave the group, or at least distance themselves from it, and try to join a higher-status one. Tajfel and Turner linked this to a belief system they called social mobility: the belief that individuals can move freely between groups. It improves one person’s position while leaving the group’s status untouched.
Social Creativity
When leaving isn’t possible and the hierarchy feels fixed, members can change the comparison instead of the hierarchy. They might compare on a new dimension, reframe a trait the out-group looks down on as a positive one, or compare themselves with a lower-status group instead of a higher one.
Social Competition
When the hierarchy looks unstable or unfair, members are more likely to challenge the higher-status group directly. This is where collective action, protests and open intergroup conflict tend to emerge.
In-Group Bias Through a Social Identity Lens

Once group identities are switched on, people tend to rate their own group more favorably and see out-group members as more alike than members of their own group. These patterns, known as in-group favoritism and out-group homogeneity, appear across sport, politics and the workplace.
From a social identity perspective, both biases serve positive distinctiveness. Attribution theory research shows that people explain the same behavior differently depending on who did it. A group-level version of the self-serving bias lets people credit their group’s successes to its qualities and blame its failures on circumstances. Confirmation bias then filters out evidence that complicates the picture.
The pressure also points inward. When a group identity is central to the self, breaking group norms threatens that identity, which helps explain why conformity runs so strong in close-knit groups.
Does Group Membership Really Boost Self-Esteem?
Textbooks often sum up social identity theory as “people favor their groups to boost self-esteem.” That’s a fair shorthand, but the evidence is more mixed than it sounds.
Researchers later turned the idea into two testable predictions, often called the self-esteem hypothesis. First, favoring your group should raise your self-esteem. Second, people with low self-esteem should be more likely to favor their group. A major review found some support for the first prediction but weak and inconsistent support for the second (Rubin & Hewstone, 1998).
If an exam question asks why people favor their in-group, “to boost self-esteem” is usually the expected answer. Just know that researchers still debate how strong that link really is. When a valued group behaves badly, members may also feel tension much like what cognitive dissonance theory describes.
Social Identity Theory Examples in Everyday Life
The most useful social identity theory examples show the theory’s specific mechanisms at work, not just general us-versus-them bias.
Basking in Reflected Glory
Sports fans offer a classic case. Cialdini and colleagues found that college students were more likely to wear school-branded clothing after their football team won, and more likely to say “we” when describing a victory than a loss (Cialdini et al., 1976). Fans link themselves to a winning group to share its positive distinctiveness, even though they did nothing to cause the win.
Social Creativity in Action
A small college that can’t compete with famous universities on rankings might promote its small classes and close-knit community instead. Fans of a struggling team often take pride in their loyalty rather than their trophies. Both are social creativity: changing the dimension of comparison when the hierarchy won’t budge.
Mobility and Competition
A first-generation student who downplays their background to fit in with wealthier classmates is using individual mobility. Workers who organize to challenge a pay structure they see as unfair are engaging in social competition.
Political identities follow the same logic. Group polarization research shows that discussion within like-minded groups pushes views toward extremes, and social proof means people look to fellow group members for cues on how to react. All of these social identity theory examples share one thread: people protect the value of groups that have become part of who they are.
Social Identity Theory in the Workplace
Workplaces are full of overlapping identities: team, department, profession and organization. Social identity theory in the workplace helps explain both the best and the worst of this.
Strong identification with an organization can feed commitment and extra effort, since helping the group feels like helping yourself. But departmental identities can also harden into rivalries, like the familiar tension between head office and field teams.
When cohesion matters more than accuracy, groupthink can follow. Dissent starts to feel like disloyalty, and poor decisions go unchallenged. Leaders who understand social identity can build teams where disagreement counts as a way of belonging rather than a threat to it.
Social Identity Theory vs Related Theories
Students often mix up social identity theory with three neighboring theories. The table below shows how they differ at a glance.

Self-Categorization Theory
Turner and colleagues developed self-categorization theory in 1987 to explain the cognitive side of group life: when and why people see themselves as group members rather than individuals. Social identity theory focuses more on intergroup relations and motivation, while self-categorization theory focuses on how context makes a particular identity stand out (Hornsey, 2008).
Identity Theory
Identity theory comes from sociology and centers on roles, such as parent, nurse or student, rather than group memberships. Stets and Burke (2000) argue that the differences between identity theory and social identity theory are more about emphasis than substance, and that the two could eventually be linked into a broader theory of the self.
Realistic Conflict Theory
Realistic conflict theory, closely tied to Sherif’s work, says intergroup hostility comes from competition over scarce resources. Social identity theory doesn’t reject this. It adds that categorization alone can produce bias even when nothing material is at stake.
Strengths and Limitations of Social Identity Theory
The theory’s biggest strength is its reach. It has strong experimental support, starting with the minimal group studies, and it applies to sport, politics, work, health and education. Reviews describe it as one of the most influential accounts of group processes and intergroup relations (Hornsey, 2008).
Its limitations are real, though. Critics argue it explains behavior better after the fact than it predicts it. Knowing that someone identifies strongly with a group suggests bias is likely, but not how much bias or in what form.
The self-esteem hypothesis has mixed support, as noted above. The minimal group paradigm also faces questions about ecological validity, since real conflicts involve history, power and scarce resources that a lab setting can’t recreate.
Is Social Identity Theory Still Relevant?
Very much so, and its reach has grown well beyond prejudice. The “social cure” line of research argues that social identities can protect health and well-being, for example by giving people support and a sense of meaning, while losing important group memberships can do the opposite (Haslam et al., 2009).
The same framework is now used to study leadership, collective action and online communities. Whenever a group becomes part of how people define themselves, the theory’s predictions come into play.
Conclusion
Social identity theory changed how psychologists think about the self by showing that who we are is never purely personal. Tajfel and Turner’s framework explains why a meaningless label can trigger favoritism, why groups chase positive distinctiveness, and why low-status groups respond the way they do.
It also explains why teenagers working through identity formation feel the pull of peer groups so strongly. Decades later, it remains one of psychology’s most practical tools for making sense of behavior in groups.
References
- Cialdini, R. B., Borden, R. J., Thorne, A., Walker, M. R., Freeman, S., & Sloan, L. R. (1976). Basking in reflected glory: Three (football) field studies. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 34(3), 366-375.
- Haslam, S. A., Jetten, J., Postmes, T., & Haslam, C. (2009). Social identity, health and well-being: An emerging agenda for applied psychology. Applied Psychology, 58(1), 1-23.
- Hornsey, M. J. (2008). Social identity theory and self-categorization theory: A historical review. Social and Personality Psychology Compass, 2(1), 204-222.
- Rubin, M., & Hewstone, M. (1998). Social identity theory’s self-esteem hypothesis: A review and some suggestions for clarification. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 2(1), 40-62.
- Stets, J. E., & Burke, P. J. (2000). Identity theory and social identity theory. Social Psychology Quarterly, 63(3), 224-237.
- Tajfel, H., Billig, M. G., Bundy, R. P., & Flament, C. (1971). Social categorization and intergroup behaviour. European Journal of Social Psychology, 1(2), 149-178.
- Tajfel, H., & Turner, J. C. (1979). An integrative theory of intergroup conflict. In W. G. Austin & S. Worchel (Eds.), The social psychology of intergroup relations (pp. 33-47). Brooks/Cole.
- Tajfel, H., & Turner, J. C. (1986). The social identity theory of intergroup behavior. In S. Worchel & W. G. Austin (Eds.), Psychology of intergroup relations (pp. 7-24). Nelson-Hall.
How to cite this article:
The Psychology Notes Headquarters. (2026). Social Identity Theory: What Tajfel & Turner Said in 1979. Retrieved from https://www.psychologynoteshq.com/social-identity-theory/

